Choosing a Formula

It can be helpful to have a ready-to-feed formula on hand for your baby's arrival, even if you are planning to breastfeed. If you end up formula feeding beyond that point, you can then choose from the broader range of powdered formulas.  

When it comes to choosing between these options, there can be some trial and error involved, but my first choice in the U.S. would be Similac 360 Total Care, because it contains a broader range of prebiotics and no palm oil (which can cause painful constipation in some babies). All babies are different, however, and yours may do better with a formula based on hydrolyzed protein, or with a whey-only formula.  

The UK formulas listed below are quite similar, and you can choose based on price/availability and whether you would prefer an organic formula. 

Newborn Ready to Feed Formula Comparison 

Formula

Palm oil 


Prebiotic

No


HMOs (2FL & others)





PROTEIN TYPE

Milk/Whey


Yes

2’FL, GOS






Milk/Whey


Yes

2’FL





Hydrolyzed milk and whey protein

No

FOS




Milk

No

GOS





Milk, whey


No

GOS, FOS






Milk, whey


No

GOS





Whey, milk

Best Formulas for Specific Situations  

Once you pass the early days and are at the point of switching to a powdered formula, you’ll find vastly more options to choose from. You can then weigh what is most important to you, whether that is value for money, the type of prebiotics present, addressing colic or reflux, or choosing an organic formula. Here are some of the best options to consider: 

Bobbie is a great option for supplementing, but if you are exclusively formula feeding, it may be worth choosing a brand with prebiotics added (see Chapter 19 of the book). Bobbie is one of the few organic hydrolyzed whey formulas in the U.S., which is helpful for babies with reflux or sensitivities. 

Best organic formulas: 

Best Probiotcs:

Notes: Gerber Soothe Pro is similar to Gentle Pro but contains less lactose and a different probiotic. Lactose is rarely the problem for babies with pain and reflux, so Gentle Pro may be the best first step. Bobbie does not include prebiotics, which is a more important factor for exclusively formula fed babies.  

Best Value:

Best Whey-Only Formula:

Best Hydrolyzed Formula:

Formula

Palm oil 


Prebiotic

No


N/A






PROTEIN TYPE

Milk/Whey


No

N/A




Partially hydrolyzed whey



No

GOS + probiotics






Milk, whey

Yes

2’FL and others, lactoferrin





Milk, whey


Yes

2’FL, GOS






Milk, whey


No

GOS, FOS






Partially hydrolyzed milk & whey protein



Yes

2’FL (+L. reuteri)






Hydrolyzed whey


Powdered Formula Comparison Chart 

Yes

2’FL (+ B.Lactis)







Hydrolyzed whey



Yes

GOS






Milk, whey




Yes

GOS






Hydrolyzed whey





No

HMOs (2’FL & LnNT)





Milk, whey




No

HMOs (2’FL & LnNT)





Milk, whey




No

2’FL




Hydrolyzed whey





No

GOS



Milk and whey




No

2’FL, LnNT




Milk, whey





No

GOS



Milk, whey




No

GOS, FOS




Hydrolyzed whey





No

GOS, FOS




Milk, whey 






No

GOS



Whey, milk